The heroine of Ho Miu-Kei's cybercrime dramedy Love Lies (我談的那場戀愛) later rejects the idea that she has been deceived for she was only falling in love and love once believed is real which paradoxically hints at the idea of romantic love as fantasy or self-delusion. There is undoubtedly some truth in what she says, if only in the fact that the young man scamming her also begins to fall in love if not exactly with her but with the image of himself as reflected in her eyes.
From what we can see of Joe (Cheung Tin-fu), he doesn't quite fit our image of romance scammer. He isn't cruel or heartless and has more or less fallen into this kind of work, learning to see it as a kind of game which conveniently allows him to ignore the real human he's exploiting in order to win. Awkwardly still living with his ex-girlfriend's family, he's bonded with her father and seems to be seeking something like familial love and acceptance along with the feeling that he's wanted and valued by another person. Of course, being a romance scammer gives him what he needs as his targets are drawn into his trap and eventually become dependent on him though it's obviously not "Joe" they're dependent on but whoever he claimed to be online who is perhaps all the things he's like be rather than who he is.
In any case, he finds himself conflicted while trying to scam Veronica (Sandra Ng), a fantastically rich gynaecologist still struggling to deal with the death of her husband four years previously from whom she was about to get a divorce. Veronica is also not being entirely honest online, posing as a 25-year-old nurse named Linda and using a random photo from the internet while planning to have some idle fun chatting to a stranger in this case a heartbroken French widower named Alain. Like Joe, Veronica is also a little unhappy in herself, explaining that she's a difficult person who blows off steam by rearranging the goods in convenience stores and has few friends. Being "Linda" also affords her another perspective on herself and a means of reassessing her thoughts about her husband and marriage.
But this vulnerability is also what makes her vulnerable to the scammers as mastermind Joan (Stephy Tang), who used to be a TV screenwriter, points out in instructing Joe that he'll really have cracked Veronica when she feels comfortable enough to tell him about her husband. Ho presents the scammers as an unusually well equipped yet old school bunch who have an actual art department to construct props to help Joe sell his fantasy though he's pretty slow to cotton onto the idea of stalking Veronica's social media profiles for information he later uses to create a bond with her.
Though quirky and somewhat wholesome, the film does hint at the dangers of online interaction and the information we choose to share with strangers, perhaps unwisely. Intellectually, Veronica is aware of the potential of scamming but also sees herself as "better" than that, as if an educated, successful woman such as herself should be too smart to fall for something so obviously untrue and is later unwilling to accept that she's sent large amounts of money to a conman despite the advice of her bank which of course only keeps her in the scam so she can prove to herself that she's not being conned.
But the conclusion she finally comes to is that if she fell in love with someone who didn't really exist, then that doesn't mean the love itself wasn't real. In any case, it allowed her to re-engage with lost love and recover herself and her memories of romance while finally beginning to deal with her husband's death and the end of her marriage which arrived more abruptly than expected. In much the same way, Joe begins to realise that he ended up scamming himself, half in love with the image he created as reflected back to him while more aware of his own needs and desires along with the emotional consequences of the scamming game. To that extent, maybe love itself is a long con or beautiful fantasy but there might also be truth in a lie and a genuine connection between lonely souls beyond all the wilful deception and misrepresentation.
Love Lies screened as part of this year's New York Asian Film Festival.
Original trailer (English subtitles)
No comments:
Post a Comment