There's nothing that breaks a family apart as quickly as an inheritance. As a cynical lawyer points out, even mothers and sons fall out when it comes to money, so there's nothing like it to to focus minds with an us and them mentality to clearly define who is and isn't included under the umbrella of family. But why is it that meaningless pieces of paper hold so much sway over us when we ought to by be governed by the emotional truths that until a moment earlier ruled our lives?
Angie (Patra Au Ga Man) had been fond of saying "because we're family." She never doubted her place in that of her partner who all appear, at least outwardly, to love her and accept her relationship with Pat in the way they'd accept any other marriage. But when Pat (Maggie Li Lin Lin) suddenly passes away in her sleep after one last family celebration the situation changes. Well-meaning family members step in to help with the work that must be done when someone dies, but perhaps unwittingly begin to take over slowly erasing Angie from their lives as not really one of them after all.
Her problems are two-fold. The biggest being that Pat never got round to making a will, nor did she think to put Angie on the deeds to the apartment they shared together or leave her financially provided for seeing as she'd managed all the money they'd made when they owned a factory and ran it together. The secondary problem is that Hong Kong does not recognise same sex marriage and so their relationship was not legally recognised. Had Angie been legally married to Pat, she should have inherited everything anyway because she was her spouse even without a will but with things the way they are she's at the mercy of Pat's brother Shing (Tai Bo). She never thought this would be a problem, because they're family, but slowly realises that perhaps they don't actually see her that way and with Pat gone no longer feel the need to include her.
Her sister-in-law Mei (Hui So Ying) insists on using a feng shui expert to plan the funeral who quickly puts the kibosh on Angie's desire to have Pat buried at sea as she'd requested. Leaving aside the possibility that the feng shui master is conning them and receiving financial incentives from the people who run the columbarium, the family quickly begin to ignore Angie's concerns swayed by the claims that interring her ashes will be more beneficial for her descendants which are Mei and Shing's children seeing as Angie and Pat had none of their own.
A little disappointed in her kids, Mei at one point insensitively remarks that Angie is lucky not to have any though we're also told that she almost gave in to parental pressure to marry a man in order to become a mother. Daughter Fanny (Fish Liew) makes lowkey racist remarks about her Indian neighbours as a way of expressing her frustration with her moribund marriage and unsatisfying living arrangements, while son Vincent (Leung Chung Hang) struggled to find employment and now works as an Uber driver thanks to the gift of a car from Angie and Pat which allows him to earn a living. He's originally upset with his family's suggestion of kicking Angie out of the apartment, but is also in a difficult position himself when his girlfriend becomes pregnant and they can't find anywhere habitable to live on the kind of salary an Uber driver can earn. Though in her 60s, Mei is still doing a physically strenuous job as a hotel maid while Shing has taken a position he finds degrading as a nightwatchman at a carpark following the closure of his restaurant some years previously.
The implication is these socio-economic pressures encourage them the abandon their responsibility to Angie as the beloved aunt they've known all their lives. But then there's also the mild homophobia that rears its head, introducing Angie as Pat's "best friend" and not allowing her to stand in the front with family at Pat's funeral as if their relationship wasn't really real because they were both women. Of course they may have behaved the same way had Pat been a man, squeezing Angie out because she had no legal claim as a common-law spouse, but it certainly seems to make it easier for them to abandon her and take everything she worked so hard to build with Pat as if they were really entitled to it. Shing justifies himself that he has to look after "his" family, which doesn't include Angie, while cruelly implying that it's what Pat would have wanted.
In the end, Angie is left with no other option than to sue for her "rightful" share as a "dependent" in an effort to force the family to recognise the legitimacy of her relationship with Pat. Thankfully she has another family in her community, though her own still living parents only partially accepted her relationship with Pat again referring to her as a "best friend" and making cracks about how she never married. But her family was Pat, and Pat is gone. Yeung paints a touching picture of grief as Angie reacts all the things she did with Pat but now alone, accompanied only by a sense of absence and comforted by her memories while otherwise exiled from a world that had seemed until then filled with familial love.
All Shall Be Well screened as part of this year's New York Asian Film Festival.
Trailer (English subtitles)
No comments:
Post a Comment